Pedestal Fan Vs Tower Fan- Which is Better and Why?

The confusion between the Pedestal Fan Vs Tower Fan is a valid one, as both these designs appear to be the same. However, both these fan types have a very specified difference that makes them essential in their aspects. But, before that, how does an electric fan works? What is the history behind the working and invention of the electric fan? 

Long before the fans took the electric form, it was a humble item that was used to move the air about. This caused the cooling effect in the vicinity, thus, making it comfortable during harsh Summers. This graduated from the hand-held types to more large designs that were made to move across the room with the help of manual labour. This comprised of the ‘single-leaved fan’ suspended from the ceiling with the help of a large rod-like arrangement that could be moved about with the pull of a rope attached. But, it took centuries for the electric -design to finally make its debut in public, thanks to Thomas Elva Edison for the invention of electricity.

PEDESTAL FAN VS TOWER FAN

It was in the year 1882 that an inventor by the name of Philips Diehl designed the first commercially successful electric fan. This was done by using the motor of a Sewing machine attached to a blade-like setup. The design was a success as it could be suspended from the ceiling and offered cooling effects. Philips also went on to patent his design, and thus, the first commercialization of the electric fan took place. The first company to make a massive impact in the marketing and commercialization of the fan was done by ‘Hunter Fan Co.’ from Memphis. Soon the two-blade model progressed to the four-blade model, and by the year 1920, the ceiling fan was a common fixture at all homes in the US.

The basic principle of the electric fan is to convert electric energy into mechanical energy. This is done by the ‘torque’ action of the Capacitor that causes the electric motor to ‘start.’ This way, the electricity reaches the motor and the coil that is wound across the metal base. This generates the Magnetic field that causes the exertion of the clockwise force motion. As the motor spins, the blades attached to it also spins. Thus, the air around moves about, and a cooling effect is achieved. However, the blades’ arrangement is made in a manner that the warm air is ‘pulled’ upwards. Thus, the air is circulated, and an overall cooling effect is achieved. This way, the sweat is evaporated from the body, and a cooling sensation is acquired.
The various essential parts of the electric fan are as follows:

    • An electric motor
    • A Capacitor
    • Blades
    • Blade iron
    • A rotor

Types Of Electric Fans

With the growing popularity of electric fans, the innovation of the existing design soon took place. The various companies were competing with each other to further improvise the design to suit the various needs as per the user’s functionality. This gave rise to several Fan types:

    • Ceiling fans
    • Pedestal fans
    • Table Fans
    • Tower Fans
    • Wall fans

One often wonders the difference between Pedestal Fan Vs Tower Fan and how are each of them different? Let us find out: 

What is a Pedestal Fan?

pedestal fan

The Pedestal Fan is an electric fan that has a long shaft arrangement that can be adjusted. While the fan’s working is very much similar to the basic electric fans, there are a few differences in the design. The height of the elongated shaft can be easily adjusted to suit the user’s needs. Also, the Pedestal fan comprises a Control Panel that has the speed controls and the switch button. The entire arrangement rests upon the circular base that balances the Pedestal fan in its place.

How Does Pedestal Fan Works?

The Pedestal fan also exhibits an Oscillating mechanism for uniform distribution of air about it. This is bought about by the ‘Clutch Member’ that adjusts the angle of oscillation. This is powered by the motor after the electric supply is initiated. The Rotating Torque, thus, induced is smaller than the rotational resistance of the Clutch member. This acts as the driving force for the oscillation of the fan’s movement. However, the Control panel comprises of two switches that can allow the user to choose between ‘Oscillation’ and the ‘Standard’ function.

The motor is both AC and DC type and functions to provide ‘power’ for the functioning of the fan. The Blades are designed to extract air from the backside and push it to the front side at a stable speed. The blades are positioned above the motor shaft with the help of a ‘Key’.

Advantages

    • Perfect for temporary arrangements
    • Great for people who travel often
    • Can be used for events and open-air functions
    • Has an extensive coverage
    • Is safe for children
    • Shows effective results for quick-cooking solutions
    • Has an oscillating function

Disadvantages

  •  Is heavy, when having to move about
  • Can tumble and fall down

What is a Tower Fan?

Tower Fan

The Tower fans ‘look’ similar to the Pedestal fans but are quite different in their features. While quite similar in its function and results, the Tower fan is slightly different. It features a Thermostat that analyses the air around. Thus, the fan switches on and off by itself according to the temperature around. One of the most striking features of the Tower fan is the fact that it comprises of the Dust-filters. This helps in making the air allergen-free and eliminates the dust from the air as it circulates. The more advanced models do not have blades altogether and are quite silent in their operation.

Advantages

    • It’s sleek and compact in its design
    • Does not occupy much space as compared to the Pedestal design
    • Is excellent for people who are allergic to clouds of dust and Pollens
    • Helps in the overall ‘purification’ of the air as well.
    • Is silent and good to look at
    • Is travel friendly
    • Is portable

Disadvantages

    • Is expensive
    • Is less powerful is a comparison
    • The coverage is not large

Difference Between Pedestal Fan And Tower Fan

what is the difference between Pedestal Fan and TowerFan? Let us take a closer look at both:

PEDESTAL FAN

TOWER FAN

Is taller in comparison

Is shorter in comparison

Is more powerful in its output

Is less powerful in its output

Is quieter

Is louder

Occupies more space

Occupies less space

Comprises all the features of a basic fan

Comprises all the features of a basic fan

Is basic to look at

Looks good and futuristic

The Conclusion- Which one is better?

Both the Pedestal and the tower fan types are quite good in their aspects. However, due to certain specific features that make each of them specific in their functions. So, how do we select between the Pedestal fan and the Tower fan:

FOR PEOPLE WITH ALLERGIES:

 If you are allergic to clouds of dust or are living in an area that is more prone to clouds of dust, the Tower type is the best for you. This is because the Tower fans can help you eliminate allergens and specks of dust in the air, thus, making it safe to inhale. Also, if you are more into aesthetics and looks, the Tower fan type is the best.

FOR LARGE COVERAGE:

If you have ample space or an event to plan, go for the Pedestal type. This is because the air coverage is large, and the results are powerful. Also, if you move about too often, then go for the pedestal fan type as it is easy to take along and does not requires any installation process. 

Liked our content? Share it with Your Friends.